Im not going to pull punches on this rant. I am so exhausted by this rhetoric and unfortunately it is pervasive in my personal life and online. I spend most of my productive time reviewing literature on various global issues. Namely land grab discourse, genocide studies, conservation efforts, state development policy, IFI reports etc etc.
Let me tell you something about the lives of rural and Indigenous people in the global south. They get their homes burned down and murdered in their sleep. Their lands are stolen from them with techniques perfected by colonial powers, especially from US settler colonialism.
The state will steal their lands and “preserve it” for use of private capital, for white settlers, or to create a national park or preserves that wealthy foriegners can hunt game and so they can parade to the world how “modern” they are becoming.
If they cannot steal land outright they will use other more complicated manners to incentivise rural people to be tied into market relations, such as dependence on ecotourism or even biochar and other technologies presented as liberatory or as needed due to damages colonialism has done. “A bit of colonialism will help your colonialism problem,” if you will.
These relations will contradict and then corrode their lifeways and distracted from effective traditional methods because white tourists don’t want to see the cattle of pastoralists when on vacation. They are also shamed by the excess wealth of tourists, and the settlers that facilitate tourism, encouraging them to become more enfranchised into modernity so their lands will either become vulnerable to direct theft or the market relations will mold them into what settlers want them to do for the benifit of their estates.
These extreme minority settlers often own like half of an entire county, while the county next door is over half conservation area. This means fewer lands for grazing and fewer water sources available for rural people. It leads to starvation and death, especially during dry periods such as the current drought in east Africa, all while the state concern trolls about food security and executes the development dance to attract aid and FDI. It also means that lands are degraded by over use because these people are being choked out of their ancestral lands. The state and white settlers then blame the pastoralists and forest dwellers and weaponize Human Rights against them, saying the rural peoples are preventing the states quest for water security as they redirect all waters to metro areas and settler estates.
All of this is the genocidal process of primative accumulation or accumulation by dispossession. It is a privilege I am able to research these situations. It is a privilege that I am able to work with organizations that work with local Tribes on the issues they are concerned about. It is a privilege I am a grad student that is paid to do this, although our union has to fight the university for a fraction of a living wage.
I am not privileged to not vote Blue. It is more like a curse of understanding. Who do you think backs these violent efforts of dispossession? USAID is never far away. The EU is never far away. The IFI are always right there. Conservation as we know it was created in North America to conquer the continent and take the land from Indigenous peoples and it has exported these methods abroad. All of this is supported by institutions and policies that democrats and republicans alike believe in and enable globally. It is supported by finance capital which is the foundation of the present democratic party
Let me tell you what people who vote blue do about this. Kenya or some other post colonial state will massacre people and burn down their homes and create a national park. Netflix will then hire Obama to narrate a docuseriese on the glorious national parks of the world. Blue voters will then consume the erasure and genocide of rural people as feel-good, green™ content with satisfaction that the world is becoming a better place. That’s it. Then they go vote blue.
Anyone who says I am privileged to not vote blue has no clue or no care regarding how the world works and is a combination being hopelessly US centric, too focused on bourgeoisie partisanship and embarrassingly naive about the world. Voting blue is the opposite of solidarity. The people who say they are not privileged enough to not vote Blue fail to see their own privilege of living in the Disney land of the global north. What ever gains they think Democrats will give them will either never happen or will be cut from the flesh of people they are happy to sacrifice.
I will not be extorted by bourgeoisie partisans. My moral worth and political identify is mine to create, not theirs to demand. My concern is with the fundamental machinations of capital and the devestating impact it has on people while it reproduces itself, and it is most destructive in places far from the minds of democrats regardless of issues in the US. I’m not going to be tricked into supporting a party that enables the process of accumulation by dispossession, and that stands on a foundation of genocide. They only have moral arguments but they do not have moral standing.
To those who downvoted: Read it again, tell me how this doesn’t fit perfectly on Lemmygrad, then proceed to go fuck urself 🖕🖕Anti-Imperialism means more than the half-assed gains by Democrats. They literally calculate this shit to do as little as possible while winning elections. The Democrats care about the Democrats winning seats. They have a different audience than the Republicans so they take different stances on social issues.
Every time I ask how voting blue will prevent any material harm in any hood like mine, I’m greeted with deafening silences. The school to prison pipeline is maintained by voting blue. Carceral slavery is maintained by voting blue. Murderous pigs are paid by voting blue. The military-industrial complex gets fatter and fatter contracts by voting blue. Familial separations and concentration camps are upheld by voting blue. But these bourgeois partisans, which-- I love that phrase-- these bourgeois partisans will keep trumpeting ‘harm reduction’ until the cows come home.
By now, I’m convinced it’s only harm reduction for their coasts, for their suburbs, and for their gated communities. Harm reduction for the already-privileged, and fuck everybody else. ‘Well, fuck them too’ is what I say.
Harm reduction for the already-privileged, and fuck everybody else. ‘Well, fuck them too’ is what I say.
I couldn’t agree more. These tactics have been used to get people to support political figures that will not advance their goals for far too long. (not to mention how distracting electoralist positions really are from what could be more productive efforts)
Liberals oversimplify politics in a way that erases the dynamic political realities of everyone, especially colonised and working people. They obfuscate the imperialist function of mainstream political discourse. The colloquial left-right political spectrum that is enforced cannot explain the differences between interests of white settler workers, Black workers, or moderate middle income land owners, yet liberals live and die by it and demand coalitions be built with it’s logic.
Ultimately this is why the Democratic Party is a prison house of social movements and marginalized interests, just as the US is a prison house of nations.
Vote red then I guess? Republicans lock up their constituents and would love to actively harm you. But you… Proved a point, or something, right?
And there’s the invocation of the boogeyman. Seriously you lot are as predictable as a period-- you act like they don’t already. Every single killer cop thus far has been some psychotic right-winger, never mind the rank-and-file stochastic terrorist incels. Voting blue is not gonna stop them, was never going to stop them; y’all never stopped them before. Hell, in several cases, y’all straight up shut down movements to strip pigs of their power and military surplus arsenals.
"Just stop thinking and voot", that’s you. Maybe the shithole you seem to care so much about despite being one of the most malfeasant landmasses in existence deserves to fall if you can’t muster anything better than the geriatric settler kleptocrats you keep pinning up.
“Political” liberals I know who spew this line are only “political” insofar as they voot every 4 years and whine the rest of the time.
Even internal politics do not really matter. Roe v. Wade was reversed under a blue President, and all of these motherfuckers take that to mean is “we must voot even bluer and harder next time!”
How long until there isn’t a next time? How long until your comfy little homes are razed to their foundations by the very capitalist crises you decided were worthy of maintaining, of reaffirming?
Incredible, as well, is how the blue guys always make shit way worse than their predecessors did, yet liberals simply avert their eyes from that glaring truth.
What about those border camps, Joe-stans? What about police violence? What about continuously skyrocketing inequality and poverty? WHAT ABOUT GITMO? Drone strikes? Growing deportations!
Many liberals seem to love being lied to, over and over and over, and seem to be utterly incapable of learning their fucking lesson.
Great post, comrade.
addendum: “I would never vote for a rapist like Trump. Tara Reade? You mean the Russian agent?”
#believewomen amifuckingrite
Roe reversed under a blue president by justices appointed under Trump. What exactly was Biden supposed to do? If there were a viable alternative to president I would love to see one but we only get the options we get.
What exactly was Biden supposed to do?
He’s the fucking president!. Pack the courts, threaten to withold reelection support from party members who don’t get in line, do anyof the underhanded power moves that the republicans live and breathe. Play fucking hardball as if millions of lives are on the line because they are.
Of course, the real answer is that he doesn’t care because he’s a thousand year old catholic mummy who lowkey agrees with the killing of Dobbs. This is what vooting blue no matter who gets you.
If the democrats gave a shit they would liquidate the republican party and execute republican politicians.
Instead they have spent the last few years sueing to keep the green party off of ballots lol
I actually canvassed for the greens when I was younger - to get Jill Stein on my then-state’s ballot.
They pay really fucking well. 10 bucks a signature, and even though it’s the greens, at least they’ve got socialists and communists in their ranks, I guess. Not the worst way to make money by any stretch.
Had a 60+ y/o bald guy in a suit call me a “commie piece of shit”. Had a 70+ year old woman tell me we were “morons” who were going to steal the election from Hillary, just like Nader stole it from Gore. That made me laugh. Makes me laugh even more that the exact same shit happened - Hillary won the popular vote, just like Gore did, but it didn’t even matter because Amerikan democracy is an utter sham.
Funnily enough, the kindest people to me were libertarians. They felt this sort of ‘third-party solidarity’ with us. They also liked the greens’ stance on weed.
I am privileged… to not live in USA.
No rly, you are. It’d cost me four g’s just to renounce my being born here; never mind costs to get out of the country 1 way, housing wherever I’m going(and because the housing market is shit everywhere, that’s probably a one-way-trip to homelessness), reliable conveyance to wherever I’d be working where I landed, and essentials to getting comfortable in a new nation where I probably don’t know the language.
It’s a privilege to not be stuck here; because for all the crackers’ pithy “well if you hate it, why don’t you leave” sisterfuckery, there are a remarkable number of high barriers to escape. I’ve made my peace with the likelihood of my only ways out being at the hands of a pig, or if an AES state opened the floodgates to Amerikan defectors. I’d Yeonmi Park this country in a New York minute.
I’d Yeonmi Park this country in a New York minute
Problem is I can’t think of any lies about this shithole that are worse than the genuine truth.
Step outside in Amerika, you immediately get shot, probably by police. In Amerika, it costs over a years’ salary for most people to have a baby – in Amerika, you are born into debt. In Amerika, you can be enslaved for jaywalking. In Amerika, skin pigmentation is a matter of life and death. In Amerika, it is your fault if you get assaulted.
Fuck, at least that train those folk were supposedly pushing in (DPR)Korea existed. In Amerika, there are only a few trains and they all smell like piss, shit, and decay.
I could do this all day. Appreciate it if you hmu when you land a defector mouthpiece job, I’m on that shit, too.
THANK YOU!! I see people have this stupid statement over and over again and you have written it very well. Thanks for writing this as more people need to realize the stupidity of “blue no matter who”
Excellent argument.
Have you read anything by Brenna Bhandar? You might especially like Colonial Lives of Property: Law, Land and Racial Regimes of Ownership. Although it sounds like you’re already well-versed in the underlying ideas. https://eprints.soas.ac.uk/25873/
Very well written.
If I copy and share this, how do you want to be attributed? A link back to here or some other name or _ ?
When I saw the upvote/downvote ratio I was bracing myself for some kind of poorly contstructed polemic, but it turns out nothing makes libs seethe like the exact opposite. Well written as fuck
Nothing makes them madder than pointing out how ineffectual and privileged they are, and how empty and meaningless voting in the west is. So they are forced to bring out the ultimate in lib praxis: The Downvote.
If downvoting didn’t matter, tankies wouldn’t be trying to take it away from you -liberals probably
Dems count on GOP asshattery to bring in votes because they refuse to advance any progressive policies. The cudgel is their only motivation: “Better vote for us or those crazy republicans will get into office and you know what they’ll do!”
"and you know what they’ll do!”
Like they weren’t doing it already, and doing it gleefully, and not getting stopped by Democrats any time Democrats had the power…