• 2 Posts
  • 493 Comments
Joined 5 months ago
cake
Cake day: February 17th, 2024

help-circle


  • There’s few different criticisms of DISCO. From different perspectives

    1. People who are concerned with canon have issues with the first couple of seasons because it’s set before TOS but has had a big visual reboot. They’d also probably argue that some of the story elements don’t fit in with canon.

    2. The first season (at least) doesn’t feel very star trek, it’s got this whole grim dark thing going on. That is thankfully dropped later and you do get the normal hopefully outlook.

    3. Characters aren’t developed very well. Even by the end I don’t think we’ve got to know anyone other than maybe Stamets and Tilly.

    4. Plots often rely on the mystery box format, which has been disappointing when they don’t stick the landing

    5. Plots are over whole seasons, when they probably don’t need to be.

    6. Because of 5 production often started before writing had finished, and it shows. So you end up with a good start, a bunch of meandering, and then suddenly bam you’re at the final crisis.


    I often find it an OK show.

    I also find it quite frustrating that after the time jump they didn’t take the opportunity to tell some different more interesting stories. Grappling with how society would have changed unimaginably for this crew compared to what they’re used too (like in the forever war when we hear how earth has changed), or grappling with genetic modification (in show the eugenics wars were over a millennium ago at this point - surely the federation would have gotten over one species bad experience with it) etc etc.