• 1 Post
  • 154 Comments
Joined 5 months ago
cake
Cake day: February 18th, 2024

help-circle


  • It was literally at the peak of the Bund’s popularity

    According to the article and specially the first quote you took from it, it was not. Their popularity was declining and the event was a response to that

    So when someone claims that the Bund was popular, citing an event, and I cite the actual details of that same event showing that the accusation of popularity is highly dubious, the burden of proof is on me.

    No, the claim was that the movement was popular and then declined. You cannot take half a claim and make it whole

    So if I claim Michael Jackson was blank and then turned white, you cannot show pics when he was already white and claim he was never black

    I didn’t realize “When the biggest event they ever manage to have is outnumbered by counterprotesters 5-1 maybe they just aren’t that popular in the country” was such a huge leap of logic.

    I think I will explained that already bud





  • Again, not popular anymore at that point.

    To prove the point you seem to ba making, you’d need to find a quote that backs the notion they were never popular

    At some point people gushed over Mel Gibson, then his crazy was made public and he lost favour. Could I take his popularity numbers from 5 years ago and pretend he wasn’t super famous ever?

    Op claims they were popular for a while and then not. You seem to take evidence from the “then not” part of the story and seemingly use it to prove they were never popular