• 0 Posts
  • 65 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 27th, 2023

help-circle






  • People keep saying that, but it isn’t true that the leak being in the disposable part of the vehicle means it’s not a safety problem.

    It’s the pressurisation system for the thrusters. If that fails, then they won’t be able to control the capsule until it hits the atmosphere. That could mean they get stuck on the ISS, in the most extreme case, or it could mean that they lose thrust mid-manouvre and they re-enter the atmosphere incorrectly. That could be anywhere from inconvenient (they miss their landing spot and someone has to come get them), to dangerous (they land so far away that they’re in danger of sinking or being eaten by bears before anyone reaches them) to outright fatal (they skip off the atmosphere, or tumble their way into reentry and burn up)





  • The problem is that their point is nonsense.

    This isn’t a long-standing problem being persistently ignored, this is a test flight designed specifically to discover such problems. They were so keen to test how the system handled problems like this that they deliberately damaged the heat shield before the flight (somewhere other than where this particular problem occurred).

    The implication that this partial failure of the heat shield is damning evidence of negligence is either ignorant or deliberately deceptive